IVF Clinic Faces Backlash Over Unconsented Use of Patient’s Eggs in Controversial Procedure know from Dr Megha Khanna
Immediate Press release Date: Kolkata, 27.1.2025 – A recent discovery has sparked outrage and raised serious ethical concerns within the reproductive health community after it was revealed that an IVF clinic used a patient’s eggs without her consent, implanting them into two women. The incident, which came to light through an investigation, has left the affected parties shaken and has prompted a review of medical practices in assisted reproduction.
The patient, whose identity is being protected for privacy reasons, sought fertility treatment at the clinic with the hope of becoming a mother. Unbeknownst to her, however, her eggs were taken during the process of egg retrieval and then transferred to two separate women, neither of whom were informed of the origin of the eggs or the patient’s involvement. This unauthorized use of reproductive material has led to widespread questions about patient consent and the legal and ethical responsibilities of fertility clinics.
It has been observed that many women have faced Hysterolaparoscopy in Infertility. Hysteroscopy is a common diagnostic tool that our fertility specialists utilize to help patients experiencing infertility. As part of the in vitro fertilization (IVF) procedure, a hysteroscopy will help us check to make sure that your uterus is healthy enough for an embryo to implant and grow.

The case came to the forefront when one of the women who received the eggs, after undergoing genetic testing for health reasons, discovered a match with the original IVF patient. The shock prompted a deeper investigation by medical authorities. According to sources close to the matter, the clinic’s records were found to be incomplete, with no written consent for the use of the eggs in these circumstances, violating both the patient's rights and established guidelines in fertility practices.
The IVF patient, who had entrusted the clinic with her eggs solely for her own treatment, has expressed her deep distress over the violation of her personal and reproductive rights. "This breach of trust is not just a medical failure; it's a violation of my privacy, my body, and my future," said the patient in a statement. "I never gave permission for my eggs to be used for anyone else, and now I find myself entangled in an ethical and emotional nightmare."
The clinic, which has since come under scrutiny, has issued a statement acknowledging the situation and expressing regret. “We deeply regret the distress this situation has caused to all are related. This incident is under thorough review, and we are taking immediate steps to ensure that this type of error never happens again. The well-being and informed consent of our patients are of the utmost importance, and we are committed to upholding the highest ethical standards moving forward,” said the clinic’s director, Dr Megha Khanna.
Legal experts have weighed in on the case, stressing that the unauthorized use of eggs in assisted reproduction could have serious legal implications. The lack of clear consent and the unauthorized transfer of genetic material not only puts the clinic at risk of lawsuits, but also calls into question the integrity of their procedures.
The incident has also raised larger questions within the fertility industry regarding transparency, informed consent, and patient rights. Advocates for reproductive justice are calling for stronger regulations and oversight of fertility clinics to ensure that patients are fully informed about the use of their genetic material and that their choices are respected at each step of the system.
“This is a wake-up call for the entire reproductive health industry,” said Dr Megha Khanna, a reproductive rights advocate. “Patients need to be fully aware of their rights when undergoing fertility treatments. Clinics must be held accountable for upholding the highest standards of care and respect for patient autonomy.”
In the aftermath of the discovery, both the clinic and the two women involved are facing difficult decisions about how to move forward. While the eggs were successfully implanted, the legal, ethical, and emotional ramifications of this breach continue to unfold.
The case remains under investigation, and further updates will be provided as new information becomes available. Both legal proceedings and conversations regarding policy changes within the fertility industry are expected to follow, as this event may serve as a critical turning point for reproductive health practices worldwide.
For more details visit our blog: https://drmeghakhanna.in/blog